Chapter II.— By what Means the Emperor Constantine became a Christian.
Chapter III.— While Constantine favors the Christians, Licinius, his Colleague, persecutes them.
Chapter IV.— War arises between Constantine and Licinius on Account of the Christians.
Chapter V.— The Dispute of Arius with Alexander, his Bishop.
Chapter VIII.— Of the Synod which was held at Nicæa in Bithynia, and the Creed there put forth.
Chapter X.— The Emperor also summons to the Synod Acesius, Bishop of the Novatians.
Chapter XI.— Of the Bishop Paphnutius.
Chapter XII.— Of Spyridon, Bishop of the Cypriots.
Chapter XIII.— Of Eutychian the Monk.
Chapter XX.— In what Manner the Iberians were converted to Christianity.
Chapter XXI.— Of Anthony the Monk.
Chapter XXII.— Manes, the Founder of the Manichæan Heresy, and on his Origin.
Chapter XXV.— Of the Presbyter who exerted himself for the Recall of Arius.
Chapter XXIX.— Of Arsenius, and his Hand which was said to have been cut off.
Chapter XXX.— Athanasius is found Innocent of what he was accused his Accusers take to Flight.
Chapter XXXII.— On the Departure of Athanasius, those who composed the Synod vote his Deposition.
Chapter XXXVI.— Of Marcellus Bishop of Ancyra, and Asterius the Sophist.
Chapter XXXVIII.— The Death of Arius.
Chapter XXXIX.— The Emperor falls sick and dies.
Chapter XL.— The Funeral of the Emperor Constantine.
Chapter IV.— On the Death of Eusebius Pamphilus, Acacius succeeds to the Bishopric of Cæsarea.
Chapter V.— The Death of Constantine the Younger.
Chapter IX.— Of Eusebius of Emisa.
Chapter XI.— On the Arrival of Gregory at Alexandria, tended by a Military Escort, Athanasius flees.
Chapter XIV.— The Arians remove Gregory from the See of Alexandria, and appoint George in his Place.
Chapter XVII.— Athanasius, intimidated by the Emperor’s Threats, returns to Rome again.
Chapter XIX.— Of the Creed sent by the Eastern Bishops to those in Italy, called the Lengthy Creed.
Chapter XX.— Of the Council at Sardica.
Chapter XXI.— Defense of Eusebius Pamphilus.
Chapter XXV.— Of the Usurpers Magnentius and Vetranio.
Chapter XXIX.— Of the Heresiarch Photinus.
Chapter XXX.— Creeds published at Sirmium in Presence of the Emperor Constantius.
Chapter XXXI.— Of Hosius, Bishop of Cordova.
Chapter XXXII.— Overthrow of the Usurper Magnentius.
Chapter XXXIII.— Of the Jews inhabiting Dio-Cæsarea in Palestine.
Chapter XXXIV.— Of Gallus Cæsar.
Chapter XXXV.— Of Aëtius the Syrian, Teacher of Eunomius.
Chapter XXXVI.— Of the Synod at Milan.
Chapter XXXVII.— Of the Synod at Ariminum, and the Creed there published.
Chapter XXXVIII.— Cruelty of Macedonius, and Tumults raised by him.
Chapter XXXIX.— Of the Synod at Seleucia, in Isauria.
Chapter XL.— Acacius, Bishop of Cæsarea, dictates a new Form of Creed in the Synod at Seleucia.
Chapter XLII.— On the Deposition of Macedonius, Eudoxius obtains the Bishopric of Constantinople.
Chapter XLIII.— Of Eustathius Bishop of Sebastia.
Chapter XLIV.— Of Meletius Bishop of Antioch.
Chapter XLV.— The Heresy of Macedonius.
Chapter XLVI.— Of the Apollinarians, and their Heresy .
Chapter XLVII.— Successes of Julian Death of the Emperor Constantius.
Chapter II.— Of the Sedition excited at Alexandria, and how George was slain.
Chapter III.— The Emperor Indignant at the Murder of George, rebukes the Alexandrians by Letter.
Chapter V.— Of Lucifer and Eusebius.
Chapter VI.— Lucifer goes to Antioch and consecrates Paulinus.
Chapter VIII.— Quotations from Athanasius’ ‘Defense of his Flight.’
Chapter X.— Of Hilary Bishop of Poictiers.
Chapter XI.— The Emperor Julian extracts Money from the Christians.
Chapter XIII.— Of the Outrages committed by the Pagans against the Christians.
Chapter XIV.— Flight of Athanasius.
Chapter XV.— Martyrs at Merum in Phrygia, under Julian.
Chapter XIX.— Wrath of the Emperor, and Firmness of Theodore the Confessor.
Chapter XXI.— The Emperor’s Invasion of Persia, and Death.
Chapter XXII.— Jovian is proclaimed Emperor.
Chapter XXIII.— Refutation of what Libanius the Sophist said concerning Julian.
Chapter XXIV.— The Bishops flock around Jovian, each attempting to draw him to his own Creed.
Chapter XXVI.— Death of the Emperor Jovian.
Chapter IX.— Valens persecutes the Novatians, because they accepted the Orthodox Faith.
Chapter X.— Birth of Valentinian the Younger.
Chapter XI.— Hail of Extraordinary Size and Earthquakes in Bithynia and the Hellespont.
Chapter XV.— The Emperor banishes Evagrius and Eustathius. The Arians persecute the Orthodox.
Chapter XVI.— Certain Presbyters burnt in a Ship by Order of Valens. Famine in Phrygia.
Chapter XVIII.— Events at Edessa: Constancy of the Devout Citizens, and Courage of a Pious Woman.
Chapter XX.— Death of Athanasius, and Elevation of Peter to His See.
Chapter XXIII.— The Deeds of Some Holy Persons who devoted themselves to a Solitary Life .
Chapter XXV.— Of Didymus the Blind Man.
Chapter XXVI.— Of Basil of Cæsarea, and Gregory of Nazianzus.
Chapter XXVII.— Of Gregory Thaumaturgus (the Wonder-Worker).
Chapter XXXI.— Death of Valentinian.
Chapter XXXIII.— The Goths, under the Reign of Valens, embrace Christianity.
Chapter XXXV.— Abatement of Persecution against the Christians because of the War with the Goths.
Chapter III.— The Principal Bishops who flourished at that Time.
Chapter V.— Events at Antioch in Connection with Paulinus and Meletius.
Chapter XIII.— The Arians excite a Tumult at Constantinople.
Chapter XIV.— Overthrow and Death of the Usurper Maximus.
Chapter XV.— Of Flavian Bishop of Antioch.
Chapter XVII.— Of the Hieroglyphics found in the Temple of Serapis.
Chapter XVIII.— Reformation of Abuses at Rome by the Emperor Theodosius.
Chapter XIX.— Of the Office of Penitentiary Presbyters and its Abolition.
Chapter XX.— Divisions among the Arians and Other Heretics.
Chapter XXI.— Peculiar Schism among the Novatians.
Chapter XXIII.— Further Dissensions among the Arians at Constantinople. The Psathyrians.
Chapter XXIV.— The Eunomians divide into Several Factions.
Chapter XXVI.— Illness and Death of Theodosius the Elder.
Chapter II.— Death of Nectarius and Ordination of John.
Chapter III.— Birth and Education of John Bishop of Constantinople.
Chapter IV.— Of Serapion the Deacon on whose Account John becomes Odious to his Clergy.
Chapter X.— Epiphanius Bishop of Cyprus convenes a Synod to condemn the Books of Origen.
Chapter XI.— Of Severian and Antiochus: their Disagreement from John.
Chapter XIII.— The Author’s Defence of Origen.
Chapter XVI.— Sedition on Account of John Chrysostom’s Banishment. He is recalled.
Chapter XVIII.— Of Eudoxia’s Silver Statue. On account of it John is exiled a Second Time.
Chapter XX.— Death of Arsacius, and Ordination of Atticus.
Chapter XXI.— John dies in Exile.
Chapter XXII.— Of Sisinnius Bishop of the Novatians. His Readiness at Repartee.
Chapter XXIII.— Death of the Emperor Arcadius.
Chapter II.— Character and Conduct of Atticus Bishop of Constantinople.
Chapter III.— Of Theodosius and Agapetus Bishops of Synada.
Chapter IV.— A Paralytic Jew healed by Atticus in Baptism.
Chapter V.— The Presbyter Sabbatius, formerly a Jew, separates from the Novatians.
Chapter VI.— The Leaders of Arianism at this Time.
Chapter VII.— Cyril succeeds Theophilus Bishop of Alexandria.
Chapter VIII.— Propagation of Christianity among the Persians by Maruthas Bishop of Mesopotamia.
Chapter IX.— The Bishops of Antioch and Rome.
Chapter X.— Rome taken and sacked by Alaric.
Chapter XI.— The Bishops of Rome.
Chapter XII.— Of Chrysanthus Bishop of the Novatians at Constantinople.
Chapter XIV.— The Monks of Nitria come down and raise a Sedition against the Prefect of Alexandria.
Chapter XV.— Of Hypatia the Female Philosopher.
Chapter XVI.— The Jews commit Another Outrage upon the Christians and are punished.
Chapter XIX.— Of Palladius the Courier.
Chapter XX.— A Second Overthrow of the Persians by the Romans.
Chapter XXI.— Kind Treatment of the Persian Captives by Acacius Bishop of Amida.
Chapter XXII.— Virtues of the Emperor Theodosius the Younger.
Chapter XXVI.— Sisinnius is chosen to succeed Atticus.
Chapter XXVII.— Voluminous Productions of Philip, a Presbyter of Side.
Chapter XXVIII.— Proclus ordained Bishop of Cyzicus by Sisinnius, but rejected by the People.
Chapter XXX.— The Burgundians embrace Christianity under Theodosius the Younger.
Chapter XXXI.— Nestorius harasses the Macedonians.
Chapter XXXII.— Of the Presbyter Anastasius, by whom the Faith of Nestorius was perverted.
Chapter XXXIII.— Desecration of the Altar of the Great Church by Runaway Slaves.
Chapter XXXIV.— Synod at Ephesus against Nestorius. His Deposition.
Chapter XXXVI.— The Author’s Opinion of the Validity of Translations from One See to Another.
Chapter XXXVII.— Miracle performed by Silvanus Bishop of Troas formerly of Philippopolis.
Chapter XXXVIII.— Many of the Jews in Crete embrace the Christian Faith.
Chapter XXXIX.— Preservation of the Church of the Novatians from Fire.
Chapter XL.— Proclus succeeds Maximian Bishop of Constantinople.
Chapter XLI.— Excellent Qualities of Proclus.
Chapter XLII.— Panegyric of the Emperor Theodosius Younger.
Chapter XLIII.— Calamities of the Barbarians who had been the Usurper John’s Allies.
Chapter XLIV.— Marriage of the Emperor Valentinian with Eudoxia the Daughter of Theodosius.
Chapter XLVI.— Death of Paul Bishop of the Novatians, and Election of Marcian as his Successor.
Chapter XLVII.— The Empress Eudocia goes to Jerusalem sent there by the Emperor Theodosius.
Chapter XLVIII.— Thalassius is ordained Bishop of Cæsarea in Cappadocia.
Book III.
Chapter I.— Of Julian; his Lineage and Education; his Elevation to the Throne; his Apostasy to Paganism.
The Emperor Constantius died on the frontiers of Cilicia on the 3d of November, during the consulate of Taurus and Florentius;
Julian leaving the western parts of the empire about the 11th of December following, under the same consulate, came to Constantinople,
where he was proclaimed emperor.
1
There is some difference of opinion as to the exact year of the recall of Athanasius.
Baronius and others allege that this took place in 338 a.d., the year after the death
of Constantine; but Valesius maintains that Athanasius was recalled the year preceding.
This he infers from the words of Athanasius (Apol. c. Arian, 61), and the title of
the letter which Constantine the younger addressed to the church in Alexandria.
There is some difference of opinion as to the exact year of the recall of Athanasius.
Baronius and others allege that this took place in 338 a.d., the year after the death
of Constantine; but Valesius maintains that Athanasius was recalled the year preceding.
This he infers from the words of Athanasius (Apol. c. Arian, 61), and the title of
the letter which Constantine the younger addressed to the church in Alexandria.
And as I must needs speak of the character of this prince who was eminently distinguished for his learning, let not his admirers
expect that I should attempt a pompous rhetorical style, as if it were necessary to make the delineation correspond with the
dignity of the subject: for my object being to compile a history of the Christian religion, it is both proper in order to
the being better understood, and consistent with my original purpose, to maintain a humble and unaffected style.
2
Cf. I. 1.
However, it is proper to describe his person, birth, education, and the manner in which he became possessed of the sovereignty;
and in order to do this it will be needful to enter into some antecedent details. Constantine who gave Byzantium his own name,
had two brothers named Dalmatius and Constantius, the offspring of the same father, but by a different mother. The former
of these had a son who bore his own name: the latter had two sons, Gallus and Julian. Now as on the death of Constantine who
founded Constantinople, the soldiery had put the younger brother Dalmatius to death, the lives of his two orphan children
were also endangered: but a disease which threatened to be fatal preserved Gallus from the violence of his father’s murderers;
while the tenderness of Julian’s age—for he was only eight years old at the time—protected him. The emperor’s jealousy toward
them having been gradually subdued, Gallus attended the schools at Ephesus in Ionia, in which country considerable hereditary
possessions had been left them. And Julian, when he was grown up, pursued his studies at Constantinople, going constantly
to the palace, where the schools then were, in plain clothes, under the superintendence of the eunuch Mardonius. In grammar
Nicocles the Lacædemonian was his instructor; and Ecebolius the Sophist, who was at that time a Christian, taught him rhetoric:
for the emperor had made the provision that he should have no pagan masters, lest he should be seduced to the pagan superstitions.
For Julian was a Christian at the beginning. His proficiency in literature soon became so remarkable, that it began to be
said that he was capable of governing the Roman empire; and this popular rumor becoming generally diffused, greatly disquieted
the emperor’s mind, so that he had him removed from the Great City to Nicomedia, forbidding him at the same time to frequent
the school of Libanius the Syrian Sophist. For Libanius having been driven at that time from Constantinople, by a combination
of the educators there, had retired to Nicomedia, where he opened a school. Here he gave vent to his indignation against the
educators in the treatise he composed regarding them. Julian was, however, interdicted from being his auditor, because Libanius
was a pagan in religion: nevertheless he privately procured his orations, which he not only greatly admired, but also frequently
and with close study perused. As he was becoming very expert in the rhetorical art, Maximus the philosopher arrived at Nicomedia
(not the Byzantine, Euclid’s father) but the Ephesian, whom the emperor Valentinian afterwards caused to be executed as a
practicer of magic. This took place later; at that time the only thing that attracted him to Nicomedia was the fame of Julian.
From him [Julian] received, in addition to the principles of philosophy, his own religious sentiments, and a desire to possess
the empire. When these things reached the ears of the emperor, Julian, between hope and fear, became very anxious to lull
the suspicions which had been awakened, and therefore began to assume the external semblance of what he once was in reality.
He was shaved to the very skin,
3
See Bingham, Eccl. Antiq. VI. 4, end.
and pretended to live a monastic life: and while in private he pursued his philosophical studies, in public he read the sacred
writings of the Christians, and moreover was constituted a reader
4
The ‘reader,’ ἀναγνώστης , lector, was commonly a young man possessed of a good
voice, who read the Scriptures from the pulpit or reading-desk (not the altar). Bennett,
Christ. Archæol. p. 374.
in the church of Nicomedia. Thus by these specious pretexts he succeeded in averting the emperor’s displeasure. Now he did
all this from fear, but he by no means abandoned his hope; telling his friends that happier times were not far distant, when
he should possess the imperial sway. In this condition of things his brother Gallus having been created Cæsar, on his way
to the East came to Nicomedia to see him. But when not long after this Gallus was slain, Julian was suspected by the emperor;
wherefore he directed that a guard should be set over him: he soon, however, found means of escaping from them, and fleeing
from place to place he managed to be in safety. At last the Empress Eusebia having discovered his retreat, persuaded the emperor
to leave him uninjured, and permit him to go to Athens to pursue his philosophical studies. From thence—to be brief—the emperor
recalled him, and after created him Cæsar; in addition to this, uniting him in marriage to his own sister Helen, he sent him
against the barbarians. For the barbarians whom the Emperor Constantius had engaged as auxiliary forces against the tyrant
Magnentius, having proved of no use against the usurper, were beginning to pillage the Roman cities. And inasmuch as he was
young he ordered him to undertake nothing without consulting the other military chiefs.
Now these generals having obtained such authority, became lax in their duties, and the barbarians in consequence strengthened
themselves. Julian perceiving this allowed the commanders to give themselves up to luxury and revelling, but exerted himself
to infuse courage into the soldiery, offering a stipulated reward to any one who should kill a barbarian. This measure effectually
weakened the enemy and at the same time conciliated to himself the affections of the army. It is reported that as he was entering
a town a civic crown which was suspended between two pillars fell upon his head, which it exactly fitted: upon which all present
gave a shout of admiration, regarding it as a presage of his one day becoming emperor. Some have affirmed that Constantius
sent him against the barbarians, in the hope that he would perish in an engagement with them. I know not whether those who
say this speak the truth; but it certainly is improbable that he should have first contracted so near an alliance with him,
and then have sought his destruction to the prejudice of his own interests. Let each form his own judgment of the matter.
Julian’s complaint to the emperor of the inertness of his military officers procured for him a coadjutor in the command more
in sympathy with his own ardor; and by their combined efforts such an assault was made upon the barbarians, that they sent
him an embassy, assuring him that they had been ordered by the emperor’s letters, which were produced, to march into the Roman
territories. But he cast the ambassador into prison, and vigorously attacking the forces of the enemy, totally defeated them;
and having taken their king prisoner, he sent him alive to Constantius. Immediately after this brilliant success he was proclaimed
emperor by the soldiers; and inasmuch as there was no imperial crown at hand, one of his guards took the chain which he wore
about his own neck, and bound it around Julian’s head. Thus Julian became emperor: but whether he subsequently conducted himself
as became a philosopher, let my readers determine. For he neither entered into communication with Constantius by an embassy,
nor paid him the least homage in acknowledgment of past favors; but constituting other governors over the provinces, he conducted
everything just as it pleased him. Moreover, he sought to bring Constantius into contempt, by reciting publicly in every city
the letters which he had written to the barbarians; and thus having rendered the inhabitants of these places disaffected,
they were easily induced to revolt from Constantius to himself. After this he no longer wore the mask of Christianity, but
everywhere opened the pagan temples, offering sacrifice to the idols; and designating himself ‘Pontifex Maximus,’
5
See Smith, Dict. of Greek and Rom. Antiq. See also, on sacrificing to idols as
a sign of apostacy, Bingham, Eccl. Antiq. XVI. iv. 5.
gave permission to such as would to celebrate their superstitious festivals. In this manner he managed to excite a civil war
against Constantius; and thus, as far as he was concerned, he would have involved the empire in all the disastrous consequences
of a war. For this philosopher’s aim could not have been attained without much bloodshed: but God, in the sovereignty of his
own councils, checked the fury of these antagonists without detriment to the state, by the removal of one of them. For when
Julian arrived among the Thracians, intelligence was brought him that Constantius was dead; and thus was the Roman empire
at that time preserved from the intestine strife that threatened it. Julian forthwith made his public entry into Constantinople;
and considered with himself how he might best conciliate the masses and secure popular favor. Accordingly he had recourse
to the following measures: he knew that Constantius had rendered himself odious to the defenders of the homoousian faith by
having driven them from the churches, and proscribed their bishops.
6
See II. 7, 13, 16, &c.
He was also aware that the pagans were extremely discontented because of the prohibitions which prevented their sacrificing
to their gods, and were very anxious to get their temples opened, with liberty to exercise their idolatrous rites. In fact,
he was sensible that while both these classes secretly entertained rancorous feelings against his predecessor, the people
in general were exceedingly exasperated by the violence of the eunuchs, and especially by the rapacity of Eusebius the chief
officer of the imperial bed-chamber. Under these circumstances he treated all parties with subtlety: with some he dissimulated;
others he attached to himself by conferring obligations upon them, for he was fond of affecting beneficence; but to all in
common he manifested his own predilection for the idolatry of the heathens. And first in order to brand the memory of Constantius
by making him appear to have been cruel toward his subjects, he recalled the exiled bishops, and restored to them their confiscated
estates. He next commanded the suitable agents to see that the pagan temples should be opened without delay. Then he directed
that such individuals as had been victims of the extortionate conduct of the eunuchs, should receive back the property of
which they had been plundered. Eusebius, the chief of the imperial bed-chamber, he punished with death, not only on account
of the injuries he had inflicted on others, but because he was assured that it was through his machinations that his brother
Gallus had been killed. The body of Constantius he honored with an imperial funeral, but expelled the eunuchs, barbers, and
cooks from the palace. The eunuchs he dispensed with, because they were unnecessary in consequence of his wife’s decease,
as he had resolved not to marry again; the cooks, because he maintained a very simple table; and the barbers, because he said
one was sufficient for a great many persons. These he dismissed for the reasons given; he also reduced the majority of the
secretaries to their former condition, and appointed for those who were retained a salary befitting their office. The mode
of public traveling
7
It is difficult to determine in what particulars the improvements mentioned here
were made. Gregory Nazianzen, Contra Julianum, I. lxxv., confesses that Julian had
made reforms in the matter.
and conveyance of necessaries he also reformed, abolishing the use of mules, oxen, and asses for this purpose, and permitting
horses only to be so employed. These various retrenchments were highly lauded by some few, but strongly reprobated by all
others, as tending to bring the imperial dignity into contempt, by stripping it of those appendages of pomp and magnificence
which exercise so powerful an influence over the minds of the vulgar. Not only so, but at night he was accustomed to sit up
composing orations which he afterwards delivered in the senate: though in fact he was the first and only emperor since the
time of Julius Cæsar who made speeches in that assembly. To those who were eminent for literary attainments, he extended the
most flattering patronage, and especially to those who were professional philosophers; in consequence of which, abundance
of pretenders to learning of this sort resorted to the palace from all quarters, wearing their palliums, being more conspicuous
for their costume than their erudition. These impostors, who invariably adopted the religious sentiments of their prince,
were all inimical to the welfare of the Christians; and Julian himself, whose excessive vanity prompted him to deride all
his predecessors in a book which he wrote entitled
The Cæsars, was led by the same haughty disposition to compose treatises against the Christians also.
8
See chap. 23.
The expulsion of the cooks and barbers is in a manner becoming a philosopher indeed, but not an emperor; but ridiculing and
caricaturing of others is neither the part of the philosopher nor that of the emperor: for such personages ought to be superior
to the influence of jealousy and detraction. An emperor may be a philosopher in all that regards moderation and self-control;
but should a philosopher attempt to imitate what might become an emperor, he would frequently depart from his own principles.
We have thus briefly spoken of the Emperor Julian, tracing his extraction, education, temper of mind, and the way in which
he became invested with the imperial power.