On Rebuke and Grace, to the same Valentinus and the Monks with Him

 Chapter 2.—The Catholic Faith Concerning Law, Grace, and Free Will.

 Chapter 3 [II.]—What the Grace of God Through Jesus Christ is.

 Chapter 4—The Children of God are Led by the Spirit of God.

 Chapter 5 [III.]—Rebuke Must Not Be Neglected.

 Chapter 6 [IV.]—Objections to the Use of Rebuke.

 Chapter 7 [V.]—The Necessity and Advantage of Rebuke.

 Chapter 8.—Further Replies to Those Who Object to Rebuke.

 Chapter 9 [VI]—Why They May Justly Be Rebuked Who Do Not Obey God, Although They Have Not Yet Received the Grace of Obedience.

 Chapter 10—All Perseverance is God’s Gift.

 Chapter 11 [VII.]—They Who Have Not Received the Gift of Perseverance, and Have Relapsed into Mortal Sin and Have Died Therein, Must Righteously Be Co

 Chapter 12.—They Who Have Not Received Perseverance are Not Distinguished from the Mass of Those that are Lost.

 Chapter 13.—Election is of Grace, Not of Merit.

 Chapter 14.—None of the Elect and Predestinated Can Perish.

 Chapter 15.—Perseverance is Given to the End.

 Chapter 16.—Whosoever Do Not Persevere are Not Distinguished from the Mass of Perdition by Predestination.

 Chapter 17 [VIII.]—Why Perseverance Should Be Given to One and Not Another is Inscrutable.

 Chapter 18.—Some Instances of God’s Amazing Judgments.

 Chapter 19.—God’s Ways Past Finding Out.

 Chapter 20 [IX.]—Some are Children of God According to Grace Temporally Received, Some According to God’s Eternal Foreknowledge.

 Chapter 21.—Who May Be Understood as Given to Christ.

 Chapter 22.—True Children of God are True Disciples of Christ.

 Chapter 23.—Those Who are Called According to the Purpose Alone are Predestinated.

 Chapter 24.—Even the Sins of the Elect are Turned by God to Their Advantage.

 Chapter 25.—Therefore Rebuke is to Be Used.

 Chapter 26 [X.]—Whether Adam Received the Gift of Perseverance.

 Chapter 27.—The Answer.

 Chapter 28.—The First Man Himself Also Might Have Stood by His Free Will.

 Chapter 29 [XI.]—Distinction Between the Grace Given Before and After the Fall.

 Chapter 30.—The Incarnation of the Word.

 Chapter 31.—The First Man Had Received the Grace Necessary for His Perseverance, But Its Exercise Was Left in His Free Choice.

 Chapter 32.—The Gifts of Grace Conferred on Adam in Creation.

 Chapter 33 [XII.]—What is the Difference Between the Ability Not to Sin, to Die, and Forsake Good, and the Inability to Sin, to Die, and to Forsake Go

 Chapter 34.—The Aid Without Which a Thing Does Not Come to Pass, and the Aid with Which a Thing Comes to Pass.

 Chapter 35.—There is a Greater Freedom Now in the Saints Than There Was Before in Adam.

 Chapter 36.—God Not Only Foreknows that Men Will Be Good, But Himself Makes Them So.

 Chapter 37.—To a Sound Will is Committed the Power of Persevering or of Not Persevering.

 Chapter 38.—What is the Nature of the Gift of Perseverance that is Now Given to the Saints.

 Chapter 39 [XIII.]—The Number of the Predestinated is Certain and Defined.

 Chapter 40.—No One is Certain and Secure of His Own Predestination and Salvation.

 Chapter 41.—Even in Judgment God’s Mercy Will Be Necessary to Us.

 Chapter 42.—The Reprobate are to Be Punished for Merits of a Different Kind.

 Chapter 43 [XIV.]—Rebuke and Grace Do Not Set Aside One Another.

 Chapter 44.—In What Way God Wills All Men to Be Saved.

 Chapter 45.—Scriptural Instances Wherein It is Proved that God Has Men’s Wills More in His Power Than They Themselves Have.

 Chapter 46 [XV.]—Rebuke Must Be Varied According to the Variety of Faults. There is No Punishment in the Church Greater Than Excommunication.

 Chapter 47.—Another Interpretation of the Apostolic Passage, “Who Will Have All Men to Be Saved.”

 Chapter 48.—The Purpose of Rebuke.

 [XVI.] Be it far from us to babble in this wise, and think that we ought to be secure in this negligence. For it is true that no one perishes except t

 Chapter 49.—Conclusion.

Chapter 24.—Even the Sins of the Elect are Turned by God to Their Advantage.

To such as love Him, God co-worketh with all things for good; so absolutely all things, that even if any of them go astray, and break out of the way, even this itself He makes to avail them for good, so that they return more lowly and more instructed. For they learn that in the right way93    Or, “life.” itself they ought to rejoice with trembling; not with arrogation to themselves of confidence of abiding as if by their own strength; not with saying, in their abundance, “We shall not be moved for ever.”94    Ps. xxx. 6. For which reason it is said to them, “Serve the Lord in fear, and rejoice unto Him with trembling, lest at any time the Lord should be angry, and ye perish from the right way.”95    Ps. ii. 11. For He does not say, “And ye come not into the right way;” but He says, “Lest ye perish from the right way.” And what does this show, but that those who are already walking in the right way are reminded to serve God in fear; that is, “not to be high-minded, but to fear”?96    Rom. xi. 20. which signifies, that they should not be haughty, but humble. Whence also He says in another place, “not minding high things, but consenting with the lowly;”97    Rom. xii. 16. let them rejoice in God, but with trembling; glorying in none, since nothing is ours, so that he who glorieth may glory in the Lord, lest they perish from the right way in which they have already begun to walk, while they are ascribing to themselves their very presence in it. These words also the apostle made use of when he says, “Work out your own salvation with fear and trembling.”98    Phil. ii. 12, 13. And setting forth why with fear and trembling, he says, “For it is God that worketh in you, both to will and to do for His good pleasure.”99    Phil. ii. 13. For he had not this fear and trembling who said in his abundance, “I shall not be moved for ever.”100    Ps. xxx. 6. But because he was a child of the promise, not of perdition, he experienced in God’s desertion for a little while what he himself was: “Lord,” said he, “in Thy favour Thou gavest strength to my honour; Thou turnedst away Thy face from me, and I became troubled.”101    Ps. xxx. 7. Behold how much better instructed, and for this reason also more humble, he held on his way, at length seeing and confessing that by His will God had endowed his honour with strength; and this he had attributed to himself and presumed to be from himself, in such abundance as God had afforded it, and not from Him who had given it, and so had said, “I shall not be moved for ever!” Therefore he became troubled so that he found himself, and being lowly minded learnt not only of eternal life, but, moreover, of a pious conversation and perseverance in this life, as that in which hope should be maintained. This might moreover be the word of the Apostle Peter, because he also had said in his abundance, “I will lay down my life for Thy sake;”102    John xiii. 37. attributing to himself, in his eagerness, what was afterwards to be bestowed on him by his Lord. But the Lord turned away His face from him, and he became troubled, so that in his fear of dying for Him he thrice denied Him. But the Lord again turned His face to him, and washed away his sin with his tears. For what else is, “He turned and looked upon him,”103    Luke xxii. 61. but, He restored to him the face which, for a little while, He had turned away from him? Therefore he had become troubled; but because he learned not to be confident concerning himself, even this was of excellent profit to him, by His agency who co-works for good with all things to those who love Him; because he had been called according to the purpose, so that no one could pluck him out of the hand of Christ, to whom he had been given.

24. Talibus Deus diligentibus eum omnia cooperatur in bonum; usque adeo prorsus omnia, ut etiam si qui eorum deviant et exorbitant, etiam hoc ipsum eis faciat proficere in bonum, quia humiliores redeunt atque doctiores. Discunt enim in ipsa via justa cum tremore se exsultare debere, non sibi arrogando tanquam de sua virtute fiduciam permanendi, nec dicendo in abundantia sua, Non movebimur in aeternum. Propter quod eis dicitur, Servite Domino in timore, et exultate ei cum tremore, ne quando irascatur Dominus, et pereatis de via justa (Psal. II, 11, 12). Neque enim ait, Et non veniatis ad viam justam; sed, ne pereatis, inquit, de via justa: quid ostendens, nisi eos esse commonitos, qui jam ambulant in via justa, ut in timore Deo serviant, id est, non altum sapiant, sed timeant (Rom. XI, 20)? quod significat, Non superbiant, sed humiles sint: unde et alibi dicit, Non alta sapientes, sed humilibus consentientes (Id. XII, 16): exsultent Deo, sed cum tremore; in nullo gloriantes, quando nostrum nihil sit; ut qui gloriatur, in Domino glorietur (Jerem. IX, 23, 24): ne pereant de via justa, in qua jam ambulare coeperunt, dum sibi hoc ipsum assignant, quod in ea sunt. His verbis usus est et Apostolus, ubi ait, Cum timore et tremore vestram ipsorum salutem operamini. Et 0931 ostendens quare cum timore et tremore: Deus est enim, inquit, qui operatur in vobis et velle et operari, pro bona voluntate (Philipp. II, 12, 13). Non enim habebat hunc timorem et tremorem, qui dicebat in abundantia sua, Non movebor in aeternum. Sed quia filius erat promissionis, non perditionis, expertus Deo paululum deserente quid esset ipse: Domine, inquit, in voluntate tua praestitisti decori meo virtutem; avertisti faciem tuam a me, et factus sum conturbatus (Psal. XXIX, 7, 8). Ecce doctior, et ob hoc etiam humilior, tenuit viam, jam videns et confitens, in voluntate sua Deum decori ejus praestitisse virtutem: quod sibi ipse tribuens et de se praesumens in tali abundantia quam praestiterat Deus, non de illo qui eam praestiterat, dicebat, Non movebor in aeternum. Factus est ergo conturbatus, ut se inveniret, et humiliter sapiens, non solum aeternae vitae, verum etiam in hac vita piae conversationis et perseverantiae, in quo spes habenda esset, addisceret. Haec vox et apostoli Petri esse potuit: dixerat quippe et ipse in abundantia sua, Animam meam pro te ponam (Joan. XIII, 37); sibi festinando tribuens, quod ei fuerat a Domino postea largiendum. Avertit autem ab illo faciem Dominus, et factus est conturbatus, ita ut eum mori pro illo metuens ter negaret. Sed rursus convertit ad eum faciem suam Dominus, et culpam lacrymis diluit. Quid est enim aliud, Respexit eum (Luc. XXII, 61); nisi, Faciem, quam paululum ab illo averterat, revocavit ad eum? Factus ergo fuerat conturbatus: sed quia didicit non de se ipso fidere, etiam hoc ei profecit in bonum, faciente illo qui diligentibus eum omnia cooperatur in bonum; quia secundum propositum vocatus erat, ut nemo eum posset eripere de manu Christi, cui datus erat.