19.—Pelagius’ Attempt to Deceive the Apostolic See; He Inverts the Bearings of the Controversy.
But I would have you carefully observe the way in which Pelagius endeavoured by deception to overreach even the judgment of the bishop of the Apostolic See on this very question of the baptism of infants. He sent a letter to Rome to Pope Innocent of blessed memory; and when it found him not in the flesh, it was handed to the holy Pope Zosimus, and by him directed to us. In this letter he complains of being “defamed by certain persons for refusing the sacrament of baptism to infants, and promising the kingdom of heaven irrespective of Christ’s redemption.” The objections, however, are not urged against them in the manner he has stated. For they neither deny the sacrament of baptism to infants, nor do they promise the kingdom of heaven to any irrespective of the redemption of Christ. As regards, therefore, his complaint of being defamed by sundry persons, he has set it forth in such terms as to be able to give a ready answer to the alleged charge against him, without injury to his own dogma.
19. Quomodo autem Pelagius obrepere tentaverit ad fallendum etiam Apostolicae Sedis episcopale judicium in hac ipsa quaestione de Baptismate parvulorum, diligenter attendite. In litteris enim quas Romam misit ad beatae memoriae papam Innocentium, quoniam in corpore eum non invenerunt, et sancto papae Zosimo datae sunt, atque ad nos inde directae, dicit «se ab hominibus infamari, quod neget parvulis Baptismi sacramentum, et absque redemptione Christi aliquibus coelorum regna promittat.» Sed non sic illis haec objiciuntur, ut posuit. Nam neque parvulis negant Baptismi sacramentum, nec absque redemptione Christi aliquibus coelorum regna promittunt. Itaque unde se queritur infamari, eo modo proposuit, ut facile posset crimini objecto, salvo suo dogmate, respondere.